FCC Can Now Enforce Net Neutrality

Thursday, April 24, 2008 by Mistlee

Can't see any images? -!

Recent Articles

Pay An ISP Surcharge To Use P2P?
There is an interesting idea being floated out of SXSW on how to deal with privacy and piracy by proposing a five dollar surcharge on users of P2P technologies at the ISP level. Griffin's idea is to collect a fee from internet...

British ISPs Jump Into Behavioral Targeting
According to Herald Tribune three major internet service providers in Britain (British Telecommunications, TalkTalk and Virgin Media) have jumped into the growing Behavioral Targeting and Online Advertising...

Is The Internet Public?
In the United States, we have some pretty easy-to-remember guidelines on what constitutes "public" and "private." Areas like your home and your car are considered private. With a few notable exceptions...

Charging Subscribers Based On Usage
TWC to squeeze heavy bandwidth users... As one major broadband provider prepares to test a pay by usage Internet scheme, we are reminded of the old days of online access. Names like Prodigy, Delphi, and CompuServe mean little to the modern Internet user.

ISP-Based Behavioral Targeting
In an article titled Watching What You See on the Web Wall Street Journal talks about ISP (Internet Service Provider) based behavioral targeting. ISP based behavioral targeting idea has been kicked around for...

AOL Spreads Its Privacy Education Program
AOL announced a program that will help Internet users understand behaviorally targeted advertising, along with providing mechanisms for opting out of such targeting. The company estimated it can reach 91 percent...


FCC Can Now Enforce Net Neutrality

By Jordan McCollum

One of the more interesting statements in the Comcast/FCC hearings recently was made almost two months ago, when Comcast argued that:

The FCC "Internet policy statement, in which it [the FCC] endorses net neutrality in general, 'was not published in the Federal Register and is not contained in the Code of Federal Regulations,' and therefore does not have 'binding legal effect.'"

(It actually got better as Comcast's counsel couldn't seem to understand questions about that statement, or his company's position.)

As I noted at the time, generally speaking, it's not the best bargaining tactic to tell the federal regulatory agency over your industry that they don't have the authority to enforce their stated policies. (And, as a refresher, the FCC is not Congress. They don't have to follow the rule of law. This is administration, not governance.)

Apparently, the FCC finally got around to reading those Comcast filings. Yesterday, FCC Chairman Kevin Martin told the Senate Commerce Committee that "I do not believe any additional regulations are needed at this time" to enforce Net Neutrality:

In a manner similar to the way in which restrictions on speech are analyzed, network management solutions would need to further a compelling or at least an important/legitimate interest and would need to be tailored to fit the exact interest. If the concern is about stopping illegal content, a network provider should not block a particular application to all users if that application transmits both legal and illegal content.

Join the Mosso Hosting Cloud.
Easy. Powerful. Scalable. Learn More

Actress-cum-Internetrepreneur Justine Bateman was on hand to testify as well, succinctly summing up the fears of many of her ilk (though Business Week points out some pretty strange statements of hers as well):

The idea of your site succeeding or failing based upon whether or not you paid the telecom companies enough to carry your material or allow quick access is appalling.

I have to point out that there's a really strange dichotomy when we take this business debate into the political sphere. On the one side, there are the people who want to preserve the free market by not regulating or interfering with the operations of Internet service providers. On the other side, there are the people who want to preserve the free market by not regulating or interfering with the free exchange of information over the Internet. (And now the media is trying to make this into a party-line issue. Clumsily, too.)

However, the political side of the debate may be necessary. As President of the Writers Guild of America, West, Patric Verrone, told the committee, "The only thing bigger than corporations in this country is the government. So we think we have to make clear to legislators that we need somebody making sure that that pipe is neutral."

There have been Net Neutral overtures in the Congress over the last year and a half, but none have come to fruition. Barring any real action by Congress (which is usually a safe bet ;) ), the FCC's assertion will basically carry the force of law. Even Comcast couldn't argue now, since Martin's statements should be entered in the Federal Register. Or at least aired on CSPAN.


About the Author:
Jordan McCollum is a staff writer for the popular marketing blog Marketing Pilgrim. She has worked in search engine optimization with clients including 3M, Little Giant Ladders and ADP. After graduating from Brigham Young University, Jordan joined the SEO copywriting team at the Internet marketing firm 10x Marketing. After 10x closed its doors in December 2006, Jordan became a freelance writer and Internet marketing consultant specializing in SEO. She also has extensive experience with web analytics, conversion rate enhancement and e-mail marketing.
About ISPproNews
News and updates for the fight against spam.

ISPproNews is brought to you by:

SecurityConfig.com NetworkingFiles.com
ITmanagementNews.com WebProASP.com
DatabaseProNews.com SQLProNews.com
ITcertificationNews.com SysAdminNews.com
LinuxProNews.com WirelessProNews.com
CProgrammingTrends.com ITmanagementNews.com

-- ISPproNews is an iEntry, Inc. publication --
iEntry, Inc. 2549 Richmond Rd. Lexington KY, 40509
2008 iEntry, Inc. All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Legal | Contact

archives | advertising info | news headlines | free newsletters | comments/feedback | submit article

Unsubscribe from ISPproNews.
To unsubscribe from ISPproNews or any other iEntry publication, simply send an email request to: support@ientry.com

ISPproNews Home Page About Article Archive News Downloads WebProWorld Forums Jayde iEntry Advertise Contact ISPproNews News Archives About Us Feedback WebProWorld Forum